Breathing for Warriors

Lucid Breathing, Positive Feedback Loops, and Wim Hof’s Breath Mastery

 
 

Listen Instead of Reading

 

Hey,

Here are four thoughts, one quote, and one answer for this week.

I hope you enjoy!

 
 
 
 

4 Thoughts


1. Why We Should (and Should Not) Care About HRV

“Over the years we've experimented with many different types of physiological and psychological measures. Heart rate variability (HRV) patterns… have consistently emerged as the most dynamic and reflective of our inner emotional states.”

- The Heartmath Solution

I’ve been on an HRV kick lately. And although I’m fascinated by the physiological implications of it—its correlation with disease and diabetes, its impact on stress, and so on—here’s another reason we should care: It’s the “most dynamic and reflective [measurement] of our inner emotional states.”

Of course, this makes perfect sense, as our emotional states impact our physiology, and vice-versa. HRV gives us an index for them all, which is why we should care about it.

But, we should also remember that high HRV isn’t the end goal. It’s the positive states associated with high HRV we’re after.

So here’s to using slow breathing to maximize HRV while (paradoxically) remembering that HRV is not the end goal.

***

Related Quote: “‘When a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure.’ Measurement is only useful when it guides you and adds context to a larger picture, not when it consumes you.” - James Clear, Atomic Habits

P.S. Huge thanks to Crussen for The Heartmath Solution. After taking his genuinely incredible Heart Coherence class, I contacted him, and he said Heartmath helped inspire it. I immediately grabbed the book and loved it.

2. The Positive Breathing-Relaxation Feedback Loop

“Slow breathing techniques with long exhalation will signal a state of relaxation by VN, resulting in more VN activity and further relaxation.”

- Frontiers in Human Neuroscience, 2018

Here’s a positive feedback loop we can celebrate: Slow breathing sends a message of relaxation via the vagus nerve, which increases vagal activity, further enhancing relaxation. Thank you, complicated physiology.

Practically, this is why when you start your slow breathing practice, you don’t feel much at first, but after a few minutes, you feel like a different person. You’re experiencing this positive breathing-relaxation feedback loop in action.

Complex science. Simple to experience.

Give it a shot today.

***

Related Quote: “Not only does VN control heart rate and slow deep breathing, slow respiration rates with extended exhalation could also activate the PNS by VN afferent function in the airways. This is a form of respiratory biofeedback.” - Same paper as above

Related: Longer Exhalations Are an Easy Way to Hack Your Vagus Nerve

3. A Wealth of Health | Breathing: Misconceptions and Tips (and Wim Hof’s Mastery)

“Taking control of the breath — consciously thinking about the unconscious respiratory mechanism — is the first step to improving a plethora of everyday struggles and habits.”

- The Breeze, Breathing: Misconceptions and tips

I picked that quote because it goes perfectly with Thought #4 below on Lucid Breathing. But the article is packed with information (and name drops, 😂). It covers a lot of ground, somewhat disjointedly, but I think you’ll enjoy it.

My favorite part was a reminder of something I often forget: That Wim Hof is a master of the breath (and marketing). Although his method frustrates many in the breathing community, James Nestor nailed it in this article:

“Everyone thinks that Wim Hof is breathing ‘Wim Hof breaths’ all the time,” Nestor said. “He’s not. He’s breathing like that for 20 minutes, and the rest of the time he’s breathing really slowly, and he’s humming.”

Enjoy!

***

Related: 20 One-Sentence Thoughts on the Wim Hof Method

4. Are Lucid Breathers the Future of Evolution?

“It seems to be only around 20 to 30% of the population are actually natural lucid dreamers…Maybe those 20 to 30% of people who do lucid dream are at the forefront of hominid evolution, and they are going to be the next species of preference. We just don't know.”

- Matthew Walker, Ph.D.

Maybe the same is true of lucid breathers? Interestingly, Nature made it difficult to control our dreams. It made it simple to control our breath—though most of us sleep right through it.

But control over our breath was not an accident. As Belisa Vranich and Brian Sabin tell us in Breathing for Warriors, “It's an invitation, an opportunity to take part in our own nature and evolution.”

So wake up in your breath. Use it to control this dream we call living.

 
 
 
 

1 Quote

“The quality of our breath expresses our inner feelings.”

- TKV Desikachar

P.S. I found that quote here.

 
 
 
 

1 Answer

Category: Heart and Breath Pacemakers

Answer: Although our heartbeat is controlled by pacemakers in the heart, the breathing pacemakers are located here.

…

(Cue the Jeopardy! music.)

…

Question: What is the brainstem?

In good breath,

Nick Heath, T1D, PhD
Diabetes is Tiny. You are Mighty.

P.S. My anxiety does not define me

 
 
 

Sign Up For The Breathing 411

Each Monday, I curate and synthesize information from scientific journals, books, articles, and podcasts to share 4 thoughts, 1 quote, and 1 answer (like "Jeopardy!") related to breathing. It’s a fun way to learn something new each week.

 
 

Nerdy Warriors of the Breath, Investing, and a Useful Look at HRV

 
 

Listen Instead of Reading

 

Greetings,

Here are four thoughts, one quote, and one answer for this week.

Enjoy!

 
 
 
 

4 Thoughts


1. A Practical Look at HRV and Resiliency

“Resilience is the ability to return to normalcy, according to Jen Baker, director of athletics and recreation at John Hopkins University, a graduate of the US Naval Academy. It's your ability to bounce back and thrive, replace worry with objective things, to navigate and take steps forward.”

- Belisa Vranich & Brian Sabin, Breathing for Warriors

Slow breathing significantly increases heart rate variability (HRV) and, subsequently, increases resiliency. This has been shown time and time again. But, from a practical perspective, what does it mean to “increase resiliency?”

Does it mean you’ll never experience stress or anxiety again? No, certainly not. What it means is that the stressors won’t feel as severe and, as Jen Baker says, that you’ll bounce back faster. The stress is the same. You’re different.

So here’s to not trying to escape the world and its stressors, but instead having the tools—one being slow breathing—to bounce back to normalcy faster.

***

Related Quote: “To say that learning breath control is the most important component to forging mental toughness would not be an overstatement.” -Mark Divine, Retired U.S. Navy SEAL Commander

Related Quote: “By modulating the stress response via vagal stimulation from conscious breathing exercises, people can bolster their resilience to all forms of negative stressors; diabetes is no exception.” - Evan Soroka, Yoga Therapy for Diabetes

2. Where Are You Investing Your Breathing: GameStop or Real Estate?

Slow breathing methods can be “life-changing,” according to James Nestor. But, “they can also take a while, especially for those with…chronic conditions.” On the other end of the spectrum, he says methods like Tummo restore balance with a “violent shove,” which can also be helpful for some.

So how do you know which is right for you?

I liken it to investing. Slow, nasal breathing is like putting your money in real estate or an index fund. It’s pretty safe. There will be fewer ups and downs, and you’re almost guaranteed a positive return.

The “violent shove” techniques, on the other hand, are like investing in GameStop or crypto. You might see some incredible benefits in just one day. But, you also risk a significant loss the next if you're not diligent with it.

So the question is: Are you looking for short-term gains or long-term compounding? Are you timing the market or playing the long game? Maybe you want to have a “diversified portfolio” : ) There’s no right or wrong answer. Only you know which approach is right for you.

3. “'Email Apnea' Is a Real Thing-Here's How to Stop Holding Your Breath While Working (and Feel Less Stressed)”

“Learning (and really practicing) basic breathing techniques can also help reverse the effects of email apnea; it'll help you improve awareness of your own breath and breathing habits and teach you how to breathe more easily during times of stress.”

- Real Simple, ‘Email Apnea’ is a Real Thing

This article provides an excellent summary of email apnea and some practical things you can do to reduce how often it occurs. Or, at the very least, to help reverse some of its harmful effects.

As someone who still (after years of a daily breathing practice) occasionally experiences this, I thoroughly enjoyed the read. I hope you do too!

4. Nerdy Warriors of the Breath

“The old-school philosophers knew it was really hard to live in integrity with our highest ideals. They told us we needed to be WARRIORS of the mind, not mere librarians of the mind.”

- Brian Johnson

Meaning we have to live our philosophy, not simply recite it to other people. The same is true with breathing. But, with breathing, both are critical.

We have to be warriors of the breath. We have to live it and practice it, in easy and difficult circumstances. But, we also need to be librarians of the breath.

We need to have the science ready in our back pocket. We need to intrigue people with the experience, then back it up with the science, or vice-versa.

So here’s to being nerdy warriors of the breath, accomplishing great things with our practice, and then explaining the physiology of how it worked : )

***

Related: Breathing Science Library

Related: Rucking 100 Miles for Breathing

Extra Thought: Breathing I’m Exploring

I try my best to be a breathing warrior, and I practice every single day. I don’t share too much about it because everyone’s practice is their own. But, here are a couple of new things I’ve tried recently:

Breathwrk App: I’ve been having fun doing 1-3 min of each breath they offer. I use it sporadically throughout the day just to try something different. My three favorite breaths so far are:

  1. No Worries

  2. Clear Mind

  3. Calm

Open: I’ve also taken a few on-demand breathwork classes through Open. I usually enjoy being in control, but I have genuinely loved these classes. Here are my two favorites (thanks Crussen!):

  • Heart Coherence (this one was truly incredible)

  • Symmetry (box breathing w/music—an excellent mix)

Here’s to never-ending growth, learning, and exploration of the breath.

 
 
 
 

1 Quote

“There is another side of Kanchenjunga and of every mountain—the side that has never been photographed and turned into postcards. That is the only side worth seeing.”

- Thomas Merton

 
 
 
 

1 Answer

Category: Breathing in Libraries

Answer: One of the first mentions of nasal breathing in a medical text occurred in this year and document.

…

(Cue the Jeopardy! music.)

…

Question: What is 1500 BCE, in the Ebers Papyrus?

P.S. I found this in Breath.

In good breath,

Nick Heath, T1D, PhD
Diabetes is Tiny. You are Mighty.

P.S. “NO GAME SCHEDULED”

 
 
 

Sign Up For The Breathing 411

Each Monday, I curate and synthesize information from scientific journals, books, articles, and podcasts to share 4 thoughts, 1 quote, and 1 answer (like "Jeopardy!") related to breathing. It’s a fun way to learn something new each week.

 
 

Phil Jackson on Focused Breathing, Nature’s CO2 Trick, and Wisdom of Yoga

 
 

Listen Instead of Reading

 

Hey,

Here are four thoughts, one quote, and one answer for this week. Enjoy!

 
 
 
 

4 Thoughts


1. Don’t Let Your Breathing Get Featured to Death

“The answer starts with the noble intentions of engineers. Most technology and product design projects must combat feature creep, the tendency for things to become incrementally more complex until they no longer perform their original functions very well.”

- Chip and Dan Heath, Made To Stick

Breathing practices are simple. But, as humans, we tend to make things more complex. We let “feature creep” take over (guilty here). As Chip and Dan tell us, it’s an innocent process, but sooner or later, things get “featured to death.”

Feature creep can be seen in breathing in many ways—the infinite number of methods available, the untold number of bio-monitors you can wear, the countless places you can focus each breath.

These are all awesome things, and we should always be trying to improve our breathing. But, if your practice has lost its original function (relaxation, focus, etc.), then maybe it’s creeping too far.

Here’s to keeping our breathing fun and adding things that bring it more to life, not feature it to death.

***

Related Quote: “The hardest thing in the world is to simplify your life because everything is pulling you to be more and more complex.” - Yvon Chouinard, Patagonia Founder

P.S. I find this to be more of an art than science with my practice. What’s “too much” for me might seem like “not enough” for you, so it’s very personalized.

2. How Nature Tricked Us into Thinking Carbon Dioxide is So Important

When you get interested in breathing, you eventually get fascinated by carbon dioxide (CO2). The more you learn, the more you feel like you’ve been duped the whole time: “Breathing is really about CO2, not oxygen.”

Everywhere you look, this makes sense:

It just seems like CO2, not oxygen, is the star of breathing.

But just when you think you have it figured out, Nassim Taleb reminds you of the brilliance of Nature:

“It is all about redundancy. Nature likes to overinsure itself. Layers of redundancy are the central risk management property of natural systems.”

- Nassim Taleb, Antifragile

Ah-ha, reading this passage through the lens of breathing, we see it is really about oxygen. Nature is just smarter than us.

Nature built in layers of redundancy to ensure we always have enough—from our perspective, it seems wasteful. But paradoxically, that wasteful appearance is precisely due to how vital oxygen is.

As Taleb says, “Redundancy is ambiguous because it seems like a waste if nothing unusual happens. Except that something unusual happens—usually.”

There’s no real practical wisdom here, just fun to consider the genius of Nature and evolution. Here’s to never-ending learning and never-ending 🤯

***

Related Quote: "And if the traveler is fortunate…the destination is two miles farther away for every mile he or she travels." - George Leonard

3. Breathe through Your Nose! Modern Research Confirms the Wisdom of the Yoga Tradition

“Quite rightly, it revealed that breathing through the nose led to a 10 – 15% higher oxidation of the blood.”

- Eddie Weitzberg, M.D. Ph.D.,

Breathe Through The Nose! Modern research confirms…

Of course, if I see an article that starts with “Breathe through the nose!” I’m going to read it and share it : )

And even better, this one was written by one of the pioneers in nasal nitric oxide research, Dr. Weitzberg. He was part of the (now somewhat famous) study showing nose breathing increases oxygen by 10-20%.

It’s a quick read and a good reminder of how powerful nasal nitric oxide is.

Enjoy!

***

P.S. Check out the 3rd paragraph in the grey box titled “Nadi Shodana – to counter asthma.” It’s the best explanation I’ve heard for pinching your nose closed on a breath hold.

4. Phil Jackson on Focused Breathing Before a Big Game

“When we made it to our banquet room, five minutes ahead of schedule, every player was already in his spot ready to sit and breathe together.”

- Phil Jackson, Foreword in The Mindful Athlete

This was the morning of Game 7 in the 2002 Western Conference Finals. The Lakers won in overtime. Phil Jackson said the players kept the same cool on the court in overtime as they had in the banquet room breathing together.

Did they win because of breathing? Of course not. But did it help? Probably.

As Phil goes on to say:

“A lot of athletes think the trick to getting better is to just work harder, but there is a great power in non-action and non-thinking. The hardest thing after all the work and all the time spent on training and technique is just being fully present in the moment.”

Focused breathing helped the Lakers achieve just that.

 
 
 
 

1 Quote

“Breathing is the only system in the body that is both automatic and also under our control. That's not an accident of nature, not a coincidence. It's an invitation, an opportunity to take part in our own nature and evolution.”

– Dr. Belisa Vranich and Brian Sabin, Breathing for Warriors

 
 
 
 

1 Answer

Category: Nature and Oxygen

Answer: Although still up for debate, it is recognized that these trees generally give off the most oxygen.

…

(Cue the Jeopardy! music.)

…

Question: What are Douglas-fir, spruce, true fir, beech, and maple?

In good breath,

Nick Heath, T1D, PhD
Diabetes is Tiny. You are Mighty.

P.S. Liked them and adopted them

 
 
 

Sign Up For The Breathing 411

Each Monday, I curate and synthesize information from scientific journals, books, articles, and podcasts to share 4 thoughts, 1 quote, and 1 answer (like "Jeopardy!") related to breathing. It’s a fun way to learn something new each week.